97 points Wine Advocate
This is a benchmark in Australian Riesling and widely loved by collectors. The wine ages gracefully and slowly; the latent power that is stowed away on release is revealed in time, making this one of the greats in Australia. So here, the 2024 Polish Hill Riesling is thunderous and rolling in its intensity and energy. The citrus fruits gather speed over a grounding of crushed rocks and minerals, while the finish culminates in a sandstorm of flavor and texture. This is an excellent wine. It is fleshy and powerful, tightly coiled and salty. It's so good. 12.1% alcohol, sealed under screw cap.

93 points Vinous Media
Drinking window: 2030 - 2040
The 2024 Riesling Polish Hill jumps out of the glass with its purity and exotic guava, melon, citrus aromas, keeping a bright, well-composed shape. Chalky textures and firm acidity provide a strong base to its flavors in an angular, acid-driven style with undeniable power and length.